← The Latest

Whose Smoke Is This? What the Presumption Means When the Adjuster Doubts It

A new California law presumes smoke damage in a surviving home came from the wildfire, in certain cases. Here is what that means if your insurance company has doubts.

Whose smoke is this?

That is the question you might hear from an adjuster after a wildfire, when soot shows up inside a house that did not burn. Say you live in Pasadena. The fire passed, your home is still standing, and you are looking at a gray film on the ceilings. You also remember that your heating and cooling system was running while the fire burned. The adjuster brings that up.

A new law, AB 1795, the Smoke Damage Recovery Act, speaks to that moment. It is about homes that survived a fire but took in smoke, ash or soot. The Department of Insurance describes it as the first set of standards in the nation built on science for how such homes are investigated, tested and restored.

Now picture the house across the street. It sits in the same ZIP code, has the same gray film, and was hit by the same fire. The one difference is that the neighbor's system was switched off that day. Does the difference change the outcome? Let's see.

Start with the zone. The law calls this the wildfire impact zone: any ZIP code that falls inside the fire perimeter, even in part. You and your neighbor both live in one. So when smoke, ash, soot or char from the wildfire turns up inside either house, the law presumes the fire is where the damage began. The insurance company may try to prove otherwise, and your running system is the sort of fact it might point to. But making that case falls to the company.

That is the point of the word presumed. It sets the starting line. The company, not you, has to show the smoke came from somewhere else. Whether a particular home or claim qualifies still depends on the facts and your policy, so nothing here is a promise.

Several other pieces follow. Until now, survivors often found themselves lining up and paying for testing on their own, just to document the contamination. Under the new law, the sampling and testing needed to restore the home and make it fit to live in become the insurance company's bill. Additional living expense benefits cannot be ended before a qualifying home is restored and safe to move back into. You keep the right to pick your own restoration contractor. And any adjuster who works a smoke claim has to be trained for it.

One caution. These standards look forward. They do not reach smoke damage from the January 2025 Eaton and Palisades fires, and those claims are handled under the rules already in place. The Eaton Fire started about 5 miles from the center of Pasadena, so this is not a distant subject here. The state has yet to set the contamination numbers, too.

The calendar is staged. The first provisions begin January 1, 2027. Remaining pieces arrive on January 1, 2028 and July 1, 2029. Its reach is residential property insurance.

So what should you do today? Take dated photos of every room, ceiling and vent. Then ask your agent or broker, "If smoke got into my home, who pays for testing, and what does my policy say about living costs while we wait?"

Keep the photos with your policy.

About Pasadena

Bungalow country

Pasadena, Los Angeles County

Pasadena is the home of the California bungalow. Brothers Charles and Henry Greene designed the Gamble House here in 1908 for an heir to the Procter and Gamble fortune, fitting its teak and mahogany interior together like fine furniture. The house is open for tours, and the nearby Bungalow Heaven neighborhood preserves hundreds of more modest Craftsman homes.